Talent Optimizers Blog

The Most Important Predictive Index Factor Combinations (And When Each One Matters Most)

Written by Damon Clark | Jan 14, 2026 4:00:00 PM

So… Which Factor Combinations Matter Most?

 

Let's start with what a Factor Combination is.


In Predictive Index (PI), a factor combination describes how two primary drives interact to shape observable workplace behavior.

While each primary factor (A, B, C, D) tells us what motivates someone, factor combinations explain how those motivations collide, amplify, or moderate each other in real-world situations.

Think of it this way:

  • Primary factors = the headline

  • Factor combinations = the opening paragraph that pulls you in

They bring behavior to life.


Example: A:D – Dominance + Formality (Risk)


One of the most talked-about combinations is A:D, often referred to as Risk.

  • High A + Low D → Comfort with risk, rapid decision-making, less concern for rules

  • Low A + High D → Risk-averse, cautious, prefers structure and clear guardrails

This matters—a lot.

Ask yourself:

Would you want a CFO who is highly comfortable with risk?
Or a compliance leader who dislikes structure?

Understanding risk tolerance through A:D is critical for:

  • Hiring decisions

  • Leadership placement

  • Succession planning

  • Coaching conversations

It’s also why we’ve created PI Hacks videos for every primary factor and factor combination—you’ll find links to all of them in the video descriptions.

 

Why Understanding Factor Combinations Matters


Factor combinations are useful across almost every PI use case:


1. PI Readbacks

A PI readback is a structured conversation where you explain an individual’s PI results in a way that feels accurate, human, and actionable.

I was once taught:

“Primary factors are the headline. Factor combinations are the introduction that hooks the listener.”

But I’ve also learned from PI veterans—true PI gurus—who believe:

Factor combinations are more important than the primary drives and should come first.

Both approaches can work. The key is context.

 

2. Coaching & Development

Factor combinations reveal:

  • Internal tension (e.g., high A + high C)

  • Energy drains

  • Why certain feedback lands—or doesn’t

They help leaders understand why someone behaves inconsistently across situations.

 

3. Setting Job Targets

This is where factor combinations really earn their keep.

Primary factors near the midpoint can be tricky:

  • Behavior may stretch depending on the situation

  • Predictions become less reliable

  • Job targets may feel “close but not quite right”

Factor combinations—especially wide ones—often provide clearer signals.

 

4. Conflict Resolution

Many conflicts aren’t about values or intent—they’re about opposing factor combinations:

  • Speed vs. accuracy

  • Risk vs. caution

  • Independence vs. collaboration

Naming the combination helps depersonalize the conflict.

So… Which Factor Combinations Matter Most?


This is where it gets interesting.

The Traditional PI View: Start with Dominance (A)

Historically, PI training emphasized all combinations involving A (Dominance):

  • A:B

  • A:C

  • A:D

Why?
Because Dominance is considered to have the greatest impact on workplace behaviorIn fact, the Management Strategy Guide in PI Inspire is built largely around A-based behaviors.

The Alternative View: Focus on the Widest Combinations


Another school of thought suggests:

Start with the widest factor combinations.

Why?

  • Wider combinations = more intense, predictable behavior

  • Narrow combinations near the midpoint = more situational stretch

  • Wider spreads often resonate more strongly in readbacks and job matching

This can be especially helpful when:

  • Hiring for critical roles

  • Designing job targets

  • Making high-stakes leadership decisions


So… What’s the Real Answer?

  • Wider factor combinations are often more useful

  • Combinations involving Dominance (A) tend to have the greatest impact

  • Context always matters

There isn’t one “most important” factor combination in isolation.

And maybe that’s not the clear, definitive answer people want—but it is the accurate one.


Final Thought


Understanding factor combinations gives you:

  • Better readbacks

  • Stronger coaching conversations

  • More accurate job targets

  • Faster conflict resolution

And if you want to go deeper, we’ve broken down every PI factor combination and primary factor in our PI Hacks video series—check the links in the description.

Now I’m curious:
👉 Which factor combinations do you find most powerful in your work?