3 min read

Top 10 Workplace Behavioral Assessments for Hiring and Development

Damon Clark : Jan 10, 2025 7:20:36 AM

Predictive Index big five personality traits DISC Personality Assessment Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI) EQ-i 2.0 (Emotional Intelligence Assessment) Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI) Kolbe Index Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) Gallup Clifton Strengths Situational Judgment Tests (SJTs)

Top 10 Workplace Behavioral Assessments for Hiring and Development

Behavioral assessments have become indispensable tools for hiring, talent development, and optimizing team dynamics. By offering data-driven insights into candidates’ personalities, communication styles, and behavioral tendencies, these assessments empower organizations to make more informed and strategic decisions. In this guide, we explore the top 10 workplace behavioral assessments, highlighting their strengths and limitations.

Talent Optimizers, accredited providers of assessments such as DISC, Myers-Briggs, and The Predictive Index, understand the transformative impact these tools can have on organizational success. When implemented thoughtfully, behavioral assessments enhance decision-making, foster stronger teams, and contribute to overall business performance.

However, it’s crucial to ensure the assessment you choose is scientifically validated. This ensures accuracy, fairness, and credibility—reducing bias and improving hiring and development outcomes. Validation by trusted organizations like the APA (American Psychological Association) or SIOP (Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology) demonstrates adherence to rigorous scientific standards, building trust and minimizing the risks of poor hires or disengaged teams caused by unreliable data.

Before adopting a behavioral assessment, verify its validation process. Ensuring its scientific rigor will protect your candidates, employees, and organization, enabling you to make confident, informed decisions that drive success.

1. The Predictive Index (PI)

Overview: The Predictive Index (PI) is a science-backed behavioral assessment designed to align talent with business strategy. It’s widely used for hiring, employee development, and team optimization.

Pros:

Quick and user-friendly (takes 6 minutes to complete).
Provides actionable insights for both hiring and team dynamics.
Integrates seamlessly with other tools and workflows.
Backed by decades of behavioral science.
Customizable to align with specific organizational goals.

Cons:

Requires training to maximize its potential.
Advanced features may be overwhelming for smaller teams without dedicated HR support.

Why It’s the Winner: The Predictive Index’s combination of speed, accuracy, and actionable insights makes it a versatile tool for modern workplaces. Its ability to bridge hiring and talent development ensures long-term ROI.

2. Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI)

Overview: The MBTI categorizes individuals into 16 personality types based on preferences in four areas: energy source, information processing, decision-making, and lifestyle structure.

Pros:

Widely recognized and understood.
Useful for team-building and self-awareness.

Cons:

Lacks scientific validity and reliability.
Not ideal for hiring decisions.
Can lead to overgeneralizations.

3. DISC Personality Assessment

Overview: The DISC assessment evaluates behavioral tendencies in four areas: Dominance, Influence, Steadiness, and Conscientiousness.

Pros:

Simple and easy to interpret.
Great for understanding communication styles.

Cons:

Limited application for hiring.
Doesn’t delve into cognitive abilities or motivations.

4. Gallup CliftonStrengths

Overview: This tool identifies an individual’s top strengths out of 34 predefined themes.

Pros:

Focuses on strengths rather than weaknesses.
Encourages positive team dynamics.

Cons:

Not designed for hiring.
Doesn’t address behavioral weaknesses.

5. Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI)

Overview: HPI measures normal personality traits to predict workplace performance.

Pros:

Strong predictive validity.
Useful for leadership development.

Cons:

Lengthy and time-consuming.
Requires expert interpretation.

6. EQ-i 2.0 (Emotional Intelligence Assessment)

Overview: This tool measures emotional intelligence (EI), which influences how individuals manage relationships and navigate social complexities.

Pros:

Focuses on emotional and social skills.
Valuable for leadership and conflict resolution.

Cons:

Limited in scope for hiring decisions.
Requires certification to administer.

7. Big Five Personality Test

Overview: Based on the Five Factor Model, this test evaluates individuals across five dimensions: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism.

Pros:

Supported by extensive research.
Provides a comprehensive view of personality.

Cons:

Can be too broad for practical workplace applications.
Lengthy compared to other assessments.

8. Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI)

Overview: TKI focuses on how individuals handle conflict, categorizing responses into five modes: competing, collaborating, compromising, avoiding, and accommodating.

Pros:

Excellent for conflict resolution and team dynamics.

Cons:

Narrow focus on conflict management.
Not suitable for hiring decisions.

9. Kolbe Index

Overview: This assessment evaluates an individual’s instinctive problem-solving style.

Pros:

Unique focus on natural instincts.
Valuable for role alignment.

Cons:

Less well-known and understood.
Lacks predictive validity for long-term performance.

10. Situational Judgment Tests (SJTs)

Overview: SJTs present candidates with realistic, job-related scenarios and ask them to choose the best course of action, assessing behavioral tendencies and decision-making skills.

Pros:

Provides practical insights into on-the-job behavior.
Effective for assessing situational awareness and problem-solving.

Cons:

Requires careful design to align with specific roles.
Limited depth compared to other behavioral assessments.

Conclusion

While all these assessments have their strengths, the Predictive Index stands out for its scientific rigor, versatility, and actionable insights. Whether you’re hiring, developing talent, or building high-performing teams, PI provides the clarity and precision needed to make impactful decisions. It’s the ultimate tool for organizations looking to align their people strategy with business goals—and drive results.

FREE PI BEHAVIORAL ASSESSMENT